Counting the cost of extraordinary times
These are extraordinary times. An unprecedented pandemic has been swiftly followed by an energy crisis and inflation taking off.
There's nowhere that makes more impact than the public finances. With lockdown, businesses closed, transactions dried up, profits shrank, income and travel was down. Taxes plummeted.
Spending went up on health, business support and employment grants. The gap between the two soared, and that had to be funded by government borrowing. The same is true for most countries.
We're now seeing the impact on Scotland's public finances from two years of Covid.
In year two, 2021-22, taxation rose again as people started earning and spending more. Tax holidays for some businesses were wound down. Spending fell, as furlough was curtailed and businesses required less support, even though the cost of vaccinations was up.
After a 2020-21 gap between public spending and taxation of more than a fifth of the entire output of the Scottish economy, the gap for 2021-22 fell sharply, to just over 12% of total output.
It's that share of GDP that offers a clearer and more comparable indication of the scale of the deficit Scotland would have faced if it had a stand-alone budget.
The UK's public sector deficit fell to half that scale.
For comparison, the Scottish notional deficit in the year before the pandemic ran to nearly 9%. The European Union offers a benchmark, by expecting its members to go no higher than 3% of total output, or gross domestic product. But the pandemic ran a coach and horses through that rule.
As we've seen before, Scottish tax revenue per head or as a share of the economy - if you include oil and gas - falls not far short of the UK level. That indicates that these figures do not suggest the economy is significantly under-performing the UK as a whole.
It is in spending that the big differences are more apparent, and these are baked in to the numbers through the formula for funding Scottish public services, as well as those of Wales and Northern Ireland.
Measured per head of population, the average Scot has roughly £17,200 spent on them by different layers of government. That's nearly £2,000 more than the UK figure per head.
And that is where these figures get awkward for the cause of independence. Higher spending per head is baked in by the funding formula, and justified by Scotland's different needs, for worse health and rural services.
The Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland (Gers) report was first published 30 years ago, as a Conservative government method of countering the case for a devolved parliament in Edinburgh.
It has been refined by government statisticians over that time and, for half its life, it has been published by the Scottish government under SNP ministers.
In the early part of last decade, the numbers looked much healthier because oil and gas revenue was significantly higher. That rosier outlook was used by the SNP and Scottish government in making the case for independence at the 2014 referendum.
Since then, the party's own Sustainable Growth Commission observed that oil and gas revenue should not be used to fund day-to-day spending commitments. It is a windfall, the advisers said, and should be put aside in a separate fund.
The party hopes to go into an independence referendum in 2023, and can anticipate doing so with a much stronger set of figures when Gers is published this time next year. The tax on bumper profits from oil and gas, including most of the £5bn take from the windfall tax, could push Scotland into a surplus.
After falling close to zero, the current estimate of offshore oil and gas tax is of a rise from £3.5bn last year, when the oil price rose from below $20 to nearly $120, to £13bn from oil and gas in 2022-23.
And with recent movements in oil and gas prices, that could easily be exceeded. Offshore Energy UK has pointed out, just as Gers was published, that gas production, as well as the price, has soared this year.
It will be interesting to see if the energy taxes are used in the same way as the 2014 prospectus for independence, or if the Growth Commission's advice is headed.
-
Football club to train teenagers in Pakistan'It's all about the delivery' - Alexander-Arnold assists Formula E carWho will pay for Indonesia's clean energy bill?Prince William reveals five Earthshot Prize winnersChelsea confirm the appointment of 'world class' Laurence Stewart as their new technical director... with Todd Boehly hailing the former Monaco chief as an 'crucial' piece in their major off-pitch revamp Electric vehicle charging for all, council pledgesMPs call for 'war effort' to improve insulation'I was a carbon criminal' - how disappearing ice changed a climberWimbledon's 2019 champion Simona Halep fails a drugs test for blood-booster Roxadustat - but former world No 1 says she feels 'betrayed' and will fight 'until the end' to clear her name Greta Thunberg inspired girl's solar panel plan
Next article:Man assaulted with a samurai sword at Manhattan subway station
- ·Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett REJECTS emergency bid to block Biden's student loan relief plan by group claiming it's unconstitutional and taxes most Americans
- ·The race to save the fastest-warming place on Earth
- ·The sustainable alternative to London Fashion Week
- ·Electric vehicle charging progress 'embarrassing'
- ·'Punjabi dance takes away our stress'
- ·Climate campaigners block airport entrance
- ·Africa's dash for gas heats up COP27
- ·New cars sold in EU must be zero-emission from 2035
- ·Wimbledon's 2019 champion Simona Halep fails a drugs test for blood-booster Roxadustat - but former world No 1 says she feels 'betrayed' and will fight 'until the end' to clear her name
- ·Coastline rockfall danger after heatwave
- ·'People think it's just water but it's so scary'
- ·Climate change killing elephants, says Kenya
- ·Marcelo Bielsa tells Everton he DOESN'T WANT the job as manager - notwithstanding positive talks after flying in from Brazil - with Sean Dyche now in pole position
- ·Oil giant Shell appoints renewables head as boss
- ·The race across Europe to build green steel plants
- ·Time to pay climate bill, insist nations at risk
- ·Pence aides didn't started packing up files until after January 6 beca utilize Trump wanted White Ho utilize to act like they were staying for second term, new report claims after classified documents were found in his home
- ·Protesters tackled after gluing hands to masterpiece
- ·Couple who slept on roof fund street's solar power
- ·Sustainability needs independent monitors - Vettel
- ·Boeing pleads NOT GUILTY in Texas court to deceiving regulators about 'issues' with 737 Max's control system that led to two plane crashes that killed 346 people
- ·How carbon credits might earn Gabon up to $2 billion
- ·How eating oysters could help protect the coast
- ·What you can do to reduce carbon emissions
- · End of an era for Wally Lewis as rugby league great reveals he had to make huge life convert 'for my health' amid battle with epilepsy
- ·Is climate change putting the potato at risk?
- ·International donors pledge over $9bn to Pakistan
- ·Woodland scheme considered in climate change push
- ·M4 50mph speed limit fines come into force
- ·COP15: Call for biodiversity 'peace pact with nature'
- ·Cold wave and fog cause chaos in northern India
- ·Undercover in the world’s dirtiest oil field
- ·Influential green thinker James Lovelock dies
- ·Last chance for public to visit See Monster
- ·After seven months in airport limbo, some good news
- ·All major road building projects in Wales scrapped